Workshop review: Doing Enterprise Architecture

We successfully held our first face to face workshop in London last week, addressing the application of Enterprise Architecture to strategically link business processes with ICT.

Held at The Hatton in Farringdon, it was an excellent and interactive day with lots of discussion and sharing of experience, knowledge and ideas between the 45 delegates, representing 25 institutions and four JISC programmes.

The specific focus was on Enterprise Architecture (EA) in UK higher education, further education and skills, particularly:

This post summarises the day, capturing key themes and quotes from attendees. Please feel free to ask questions or add further detail, especially if you were an attendee, via the comments.

What is EA?

The day opened with a brief overview of EA by David Rose who claimed that this was his briefest ever overview of the topic!  Indeed, a pre-workshop webinar was held prior to the workshop, introducing the topic in an educational context, allowing the workshop to get straight into the detail…

“Architecture is a function of complexity.”

Are we not already doing this?

During the opening interactions it was interesting to hear from a number of people that they felt they were already ‘Doing EA’, but hadn’t recognised it as such. It’s often the case that Universities/Colleges are already applying a number of EA principles (like those from the University of Roehampton) to their work. It can take time to adopt the full range of principles, something David highlights as the ‘Road to Value’. The more principles you adopt and embed the greater the expected value.

Institutional perspectives

The second part of the morning focused on the experiences of and approaches to EA for a number of institutions: University of Bristol, Coventry University, and University of Bradford. You can access all of the presentations via our slideshare account, with Coventry University’s shown below.

The Journey of an Institution

View more PowerPoint from emergingpractices

Some key points from those presentations and comments from the floor included:

Nikki Rogers (Bristol University)

Governance & Management

After continuing conversations over lunch, the afternoon session split into two tracks: EA Modelling and EA Governance & Management.

The governance and management session focused on three topic areas: managing benefits; engaging colleagues; and governance.

Managing Benefits
In trying to manage benefits it’s important to ask who you’re communicating the benefits to, and who they can be attributed to? The notion of a benefits chain was also highlighted and discussed—how does one benefit lead onto the next?

“Articulating benefits is a skill.”

A ‘3Es’ (or is it 6?) benefits matrix was introduced to identify and highlight expected benefits. Attendees only spent five minutes considering this on the day and even that was found to be useful, providing a wide range of example benefits. If you try this yourself, don’t worry too much about filling in every box. The matrix is a tool to help generate ideas. The important thing is to be clear on who you communicate those benefits to.

Engaging Colleagues
The session then moved on to consider communication and how to effectively engage colleagues, specifically senior colleagues. More often than not you only have one opportunity to engage colleagues, therefore it is very important to make best use of every opportunity that arises. The importance of getting your message across is often underestimated. It is important to be prepared:

At times, you can’t always get through to the person you want to, so it might be useful to engage them through someone that can influence their thinking. One delegate highlighted the way in which they work closely with the President of the Students Union, which can be very powerful in gaining buy-in from senior managers.

“You’ve got to get to the people who will tell your story for you.”

Another delegate explained the difficulty they were having gaining buy-in for their project from senior managers who are often ‘too busy’. They continued to describe a change of tactic, attempting to generate a ‘groundswell’, gaining more buy-in from the bottom-up before re-engaging senior management.

Something that wasn’t mentioned during the session, but a tool that JISC projects have found useful in the past, is the interest/influence matrix for identifying stakeholders (shown below).

Governance
Due to the rich discussions of the previous sections, discussions around governance were limited to only a few minutes. However, governance will be the focus of a future online webinar, watch this space!

“Governance is about making good decisions for the benefit of the whole institution.”

Enterprise Architecture Modelling

The EA modelling session had a very practical focus providing attendees with a hands-on experience of Archimate and Archi. Whilst participants ended up at various stages of an exercise provided on the day, they all felt as if they had acquired a basic knowledge of the language and the tool. Major talking points included:

Resources/References

Online: EA briefing paperDoing Enterprise Architecture (5Mb); EA infoKit; ArchiMate; Archi; Modelling tutorial sheet; Open Group (TOGAF); ITANAJISC EA Ning; Strategic ICT Toolkit.

Books: Enterprise Architecture As Strategy (Ross, Weill and Robertson, 2006); IT Governance (Weill and Ross, 2004); Everyday EA (Free Online: Tom Graves, 2010); Innovator’s Dilemma (Christensen, 1997).

Thank you!

We are indebted to all of our speakers/facilitators (listed below) on the day; without them we wouldn’t have had the structure to hang our discussions from. But also, we thank everyone who took part in the day. ‘Learning, by doing, together’ really helps to move our understanding and application of difficult topics forward more effectively and efficiently.

Speakers/Facilitators: Russell Allen, Ian Anderson, Phil Beauvoir, Clare Gibbons, Wilbert Kraan, Lucy Nelson, Mussadiq Razza, Nikki Rogers and David Rose.

What next?

Our next webinar, pencilled in for the 22nd May (12:00-14:00), with the current working title of ‘Doing EA: The Management Journey’ will focus on EA Governance. This webinar will be open for anyone to attend.

Comments

7 Responses to “Workshop review: Doing Enterprise Architecture”

  1. Enterprise Architecture (for a beginner) « SCRIBE on April 13th, 2012 1:27 pm

    [...] day went on, it became apparent that one thing it should not replace is process mapping.  As this blog post from the Emerging Practices initiative explains “EA provides a vertical view of the organisation whilst process mapping gives you a more [...]

  2. André on April 13th, 2012 4:33 pm

    Thanks for your post. Btw: I like matrices too as they are good communication tools and easen or reduce analysis. I use them for availability planning (risk-matrix), product situation overview (SWOT), “stakeholder” analysis and so on. To be exact, I don’t analyse stakeholders but “environment groups” (Umfeldgruppen): these include “negative stakeholders” too – e.g. institutions that use our service in order to spy on people (tax office, tv-licence, …), competitors of course, disappointed ex-customers, crackers, bots and so on

  3. Enterprise Architecture at Bristol » Looking back on the first year of my EA role at Bristol on April 17th, 2012 2:17 pm

    [...] in my new role at the University of Bristol this last year. The event was the JISC “Doing Enterprise Architecture workshop” and the slides to my presentation can be found here: Slide Presentation on The First Year of [...]

  4. Adam Cooper’s Work Blog » Analytics and Big Data - Reflections from the Teradata Universe Conference 2012 on April 27th, 2012 6:39 pm

    [...] Gade utter the words "Enterprise Architecture" (EA), many of the issues he raised have appeared in talks at the JISC Enterprise Architecture Practice Group: governance, senior management buy-in, selection of high-value targets, tactical application, … [...]

  5. Doing EA: The Management Journey : Emerging Practices on May 21st, 2012 2:14 pm

    [...] upon themes discussed at our most recent workshop and a previous online webinar, we are pleased to announce the second in our series of Enterprise [...]

  6. Workshop Review: Doing Enterprise Architecture #2 : Emerging Practices on July 5th, 2012 4:38 pm

    [...] of our first ‘Doing EA’ workshop, held back in March. A previous post provides an overview of the first workshop and in this post we summarise the second workshop, attempting as little repetition as [...]

  7. My Work Week in Words #1 | andystew on May 13th, 2013 8:11 am

    [...] Emerging Practices have organised two workshops this year, one in March, and one at the beginning of July. I completed the reviews (summary of the two days, background [...]

Leave a Reply